FILM HISTORY / Behind the Scenes

Games Between Takes: Small Breaks and Team Chemistry on an Indie Film Set

Friends playing a tabletop game together during leisure time

I spent one summer, years ago, carrying sandbags on a friend’s short film, and what I remember most isn’t any scene we shot. It’s standing in a hot rented kitchen at about four in the afternoon after the gaffer had muttered “twenty minutes, maybe thirty” and gone up a ladder. Somebody was checking their phone. Somebody else had wandered off to find the good coffee. Our sound guy, Marco, just sat down on an apple box and looked at the ceiling for a long time, and I’m fairly sure he was quietly working out how much he’d have earned that week waiting tables instead.

You never see any of that in a trailer, of course. But if you add it up it’s a big chunk of the day, and on a little indie shoot I’d honestly say it decides whether people are still friendly with each other by the third week or barely talking.

So this is a piece about those dead minutes. It’s partly about Mystery Team too, the 2009 comedy that Donald Glover, D.C. Pierson and Dominic Dierkes made as Derrick Comedy, with Dan Eckman directing, though I should warn you now that much of it is about small sets in general rather than theirs. Interviews from the time tell us plenty about how that film was scheduled and planned, and almost nothing about what anyone did with their spare minutes. I’d rather admit that gap than fill it with stories nobody actually told.

Where all the waiting comes from

A pause on set isn’t free time, whatever it looks like from the catering table. Think of a relay where only one runner is allowed to move at a time and everybody else has to stand at the line with their baton. The camera team rebuilds a rig for a new angle. Then wardrobe spots that an actor’s collar is folded under on one side when it wasn’t in the last take, and off they go to fix it. And just as you’re ready, there’s a lawnmower droning away three gardens over, so the sound person holds up a hand and everyone waits for some retired guy to finish his grass.

Bigger productions hide a lot of this because each department has enough people to work at the same time. On our friend’s short there were maybe nine of us, and the person who was supposed to be holding the boom was also the one driving to the hardware store for gaffer tape. If she was gone, we were stuck. Did anyone know how long a light change would take? Not really. We had one orange extension cord long enough to reach the porch, and whether a setup took five minutes or forty depended mostly on whether that cord felt like working.

You figure out pretty fast that whatever you do in those gaps has to be something you can drop instantly. I watched a grip try to start a game of Risk on day two. It lasted about six minutes before someone yelled “back to one,” and the little plastic armies sat on a windowsill for the rest of the shoot, gathering dust next to a coffee mug nobody ever claimed.

Picture a farmhouse shoot

Let me invent a slightly bigger set for a minute, since the Mystery Team one isn’t mine to describe. Say it’s a twelve-day indie shoot in a borrowed farmhouse in October. The cast is five actors, the crew is maybe eleven, and catering is a folding table with peanut butter, bread and a slow cooker of chili that somebody’s aunt dropped off.

Day one, the downtime is awkward. People don’t know each other yet, so they scroll their phones in separate corners. By day three, the script supervisor has started a running trivia game, one question every time there’s a reset, scores kept on the back of a call sheet. It’s the kind of thing you can drop mid-sentence the moment someone yells for quiet and pick up again forty minutes later without anyone losing track.

At lunch, which is a proper scheduled hour away from the cameras, a couple of the grips bring out a worn deck and play classic card games at the far end of the porch, well clear of the continuity props and the expensive lenses. Rummy, mostly, and an occasional round of crazy eights when a newcomer wants in. There’s nothing riding on it. It’s just something to do with your hands while the chili cools.

By day eight, half the cast has joined. The two actors playing estranged brothers in the film, who barely spoke during the first read-through, are now arguing loudly about whether you can lay off a card onto someone else’s run. Their scenes that afternoon have a looseness that wasn’t there before. Is that because of the cards? Probably not entirely. But it didn’t hurt either.

Games that fit a short break

The games that survive on a set tend to share one quality, which is that you can walk away from them instantly. Word puzzles work well. So does trivia, a quick round of twenty questions, or one of those collaborative story games where each person adds a sentence and the result slowly becomes unhinged. Rock-paper-scissors has settled more set disputes than any producer would care to admit, including who has to go stand in the rain holding the bounce board.

What doesn’t work is anything that needs a big table, a lot of pieces, or forty uninterrupted minutes. You also learn quickly to keep games away from anything the camera has already seen. Moving a mug that appears in the last take, even by a few inches, can mean someone has to reshoot the whole scene, and a crew that has just lost an hour to a misplaced mug isn’t in the mood for games afterwards.

None of these examples come from the Mystery Team production, I should stress. They’re the sort of thing that tends to happen on small shoots in general, and I’ve no record of what Glover or anybody else on that set actually did between setups.

Breaks that turn into work

Not every useful pause involves a game, either. Some of the most useful pauses on a comedy set aren’t really breaks at all. Two actors go over a scene quietly in a hallway. Someone tries a joke out loud to see whether it lands, and the director wanders over to explain what the moment is supposed to feel like emotionally. For a sketch group making the jump to a feature, those small huddles matter a great deal, and they’re much closer to the careful comic teamwork the Mystery Team filmmakers actually described than some imaginary story about an off-camera tournament would ever be.

With Mystery Team, interviews from the period suggest most of the script was locked before the cameras rolled. In a conversation with ComingSoon, Donald Glover on scheduling and preparation talked about coming in with much of the film already written, partly because there wasn’t much time to improvise on the day. Later commentary has suggested a few scenes still benefited from the performers’ instincts. Both things can be true at once, and anyone who’s been on a tight comedy shoot will recognise that mix of careful planning and the odd happy accident.

What the record actually tells us

So what do we know for sure? Quite a bit about the logistics. A cast interview with College Movie Review mentions the reported 33-day shoot, which is a big step up for a group whose earlier work was internet sketches filmed in apartments and on New York sidewalks. Our own write-up of the documented Mystery Team production schedule goes through that in more detail.

There’s also the setting. Much of the film was shot in New Hampshire, and a piece in New Hampshire Magazine collects crew life and production recollections from that time, including a wrap gathering that people still remember. That anecdote has names attached and a source you can check, which is exactly why it’s worth more than a dozen vague “I heard that…” stories.

D.C. Pierson has looked back on those years too, and his retrospective interview is a good read for anyone curious about how the group thought about the move from short sketches to a full-length film.

What none of these sources mention is any sort of card game, phone game or organised downtime ritual. Maybe there were some. Maybe there weren’t. The honest answer is that we don’t know.

Why I’m being so fussy about it

Fan archives have a habit of blurring the line between what probably happened and what demonstrably did. It’s an easy mistake to make. Almost any film crew might enjoy a short puzzle or a hand of cards, but possibility isn’t evidence. You picture a crew of young comedians stuck in a small New England town for a month, and of course you imagine late-night game marathons and pranks. Then someone repeats that picture on a forum, someone else quotes the forum, and five years later it’s “a well-known story from the set.”

On a site devoted to one specific movie, keeping that line clear is what makes the history worth trusting, so I’d rather not add to that pile. If a former crew member ever writes in with a specific memory, with a name and a date attached, we’ll happily add it here and say where it came from.

There’s a more interesting question underneath all this anyway. It isn’t which game this cast definitely played. It’s how a small group keeps its sense of humour and its patience over thirty-odd long days, far from home, with little money and less sleep. Card games and trivia might be part of the answer on some sets. The bigger part is usually the people, and on that front the Derrick Comedy story is well documented, a group of friends who had been making each other laugh for years and figured out, one setup at a time, how to make a feature.

A last word from the apple box

Next time you watch Mystery Team, or any small indie comedy, try to picture the hours on either side of each shot. The lighting tweaks, the cold coffee, the endless waiting for a plane to pass overhead. The finished film hides all of it, which is the whole point.

Somewhere in those gaps, people became a crew. We don’t know exactly how that happened on this particular film, and that’s fine. Some stories are better left with the people who were there.

Sources and context

Editorial note: This is a newly written historical feature, not recovered copy from the original 2009 movie website. Images, if supplied, are illustrative stock photography unless stated otherwise.

✦